eery, spooky, strange, unusual, unnatural, uncanny, spookish, eerisome, ghostly, phantasmal, more...

normal, comforting, familiar, ordinary, mundane

creepy, spooky, sinister, ominous, more...

little, more, strange, same, real, sound, pretty, downright, scotch, lofty, plain

strange feeling,   strangely beautiful,   weird feeling,   skin crawling,   slightly scary,   scary but beautiful,   weird and scary,   scary voice,   scary beautiful,   like ghost stories